This article contains minor/thematic spoilers for The Dark Urge’s storyline.

Baldur’s Gate 3 allows players to create either a hero or a villain using its detailed character creator. There, players can choose their character’s race, background, stats, and the cosmetic features that will define their OC on their over-hundred-hour adventure. From original creations to an origin companion with pre-set stakes and hopes, a player has a wealth of options to pick from. However, one stands as one of the most compelling choices, as The Dark Urge’s origin in Baldur’s Gate 3 is one of the game’s most fascinating narrative choices. Unlike a custom Tav or the premade origin characters in Baldur’s Gate 3, the Dark Urge (“Durge” for short) presents players with a protagonist who arrives in the world already carrying a hidden darkness and a terrifying legacy they do not remember. As a Dragonborn Sorcerer by default, Durge is already powerful, but when viewed through the lens of roleplay and character development, there’s another class that might have suited this narrative arc even better: Paladin. Paladin may not be Durge’s default class, but it’s arguably the most thematically resonant. It offers rich narrative tension, incredible gameplay challenges, and meaningful consequences. In fact, a Paladin offers the perfect duality to express both the potential redemption and ruin at the heart of the Dark Urge.

Baldur’s Gate 3’s Orbit Will Be Hard for Future Larian Studios Games to Escape

Larian Studios’ next game will live in the shadow of Baldur’s Gate 3, no matter how much it tries to stand apart.

Durge’s Inner Conflict Makes Paladin a Natural Fit in Baldur’s Gate 3

Gamers who play a Paladin in Baldur’s Gate 3 learn that these warriors are defined by oaths: sworn codes of conduct that shape their abilities and interactions with the world. But those oaths come with a cost. Should a Paladin break their oath, they are punished mechanically, losing class benefits and becoming an Oathbreaker. For most characters, this adds strategic depth. But for the Dark Urge, it could have symbolized something far more personal. The Dark Urge is a character constantly at war with their blood-soaked instincts. Their story is one of choice: to reject the unnamed cruelty programmed into them or to fully embrace it. This is the exact arc that many Paladins go through mechanically, making it an ideal class to mirror the Durge’s narrative path. A Durge Paladin resisting their origin is someone upholding an oath in the face of overwhelming inner pressure. And when that pressure wins out? The fall from grace is devastating—and incredibly satisfying from a roleplaying perspective.
Redemption or Ruin: Roleplaying Possibilities for Good and Evil Durge

Where other classes may simply ride the moral current of the story, Paladins stand apart for how their alignment is challenged and tested by both player actions and in-game choices. For the Dark Urge, this gives players the chance to explore either extreme of their arc with added narrative heft. There are three ways to play a Durge, and a Paladin class just adds an extra layer of nuance. A good-aligned Durge Paladin may embody an unshakable resolve to atone for the atrocities they were built to commit. Their oath becomes a lifeline, a resilient and righteous way to build something sacred out of their cursed legacy. Whether they are swearing vengeance against their creator or committing to protect those they once would have slaughtered, their Paladinhood represents hope. That’s a powerful image: a killer forged in blood now upholding something for the greater good—despite all odds. On the other hand, an evil-aligned Durge Paladin who breaks their oath taps into a particularly grim fantasy. Becoming an Oathbreaker isn’t just a mechanical choice—it’s a descent into something unholy. Durge, once pretending to be noble, now openly embraces their monstrosity. This path works exceptionally well in conjunction with the secret behind Durge’s identity and offers one of the most coherent “villain origin stories” in the entire game.
Sorcerer Durge Still Works—But Lacks Symbolism

None of this is to say the default Sorcerer Durge build is without merit. Sorcerers are born with magic in their blood, just as the Durge is born with a dark legacy. Mechanically, Sorcerer spells like Inflict Wounds and Crown of Madness do pair well with the Durge’s more sinister tendencies. Additionally, the innate power of a Dragonborn Sorcerer fits the fantasy of someone with a preordained role in a grand and terrible plan. But Sorcerers, by nature, are reactive rather than aspirational. Their powers are tied to lineage rather than personal growth or ideology. This makes Sorcerer a great mirror for the Durge’s uncertain backstory, but a limited tool for exploring how that backstory might be rewritten or contextualized. In contrast, Paladins constantly wrestle with choice and consequence, offering a clearer path for transformation, for better or worse.

Baldur’s Gate 3 Puzzle Tier List

Baldur’s Gate 3’s gameplay is loaded with puzzles throughout its map, and there are some that stand out from the pack.

Technical and Narrative Synergy = The Case for Durge to be a Paladin in Baldur’s Gate 3

There’s also a gameplay case to be made. Paladins in Baldur’s Gate 3 can deal incredible burst damage with Divine Smite and have access to both martial prowess and spellcasting. Combined with the Durge’s inherent combat power and special scenes, the Paladin’s subclasses would enhance both narrative and action. Players choosing the Oath of Vengeance or the Oath of the Ancients could find especially poignant storylines emerging. The Vengeance Paladin, additionally, seeks justice and retribution. Likewise, the fear of slipping into Oathbreaker status would hang over every decision. It’s a mechanic that mirrors the roleplay dilemma of resisting or surrendering to one’s darker impulses, allowing every long rest and dialogue choice to carry real weight.
A Small Change That Could Have Made a Big Impact

The beauty of Baldur’s Gate 3 lies in its flexibility. Players can, and do, build a BG3 protagonist however they want. But by establishing Sorcerer as the default class, the game misses a small but powerful opportunity in gently nudging the player into believing that the default is fully canon. Paladin Durge is more than a cool build, it’s a thematic match, a mechanical enhancement, and a storytelling tool all in one. As discussions of Baldur’s Gate 4 continue, it’s worth revisiting how class choices can elevate narrative arcs. The Dark Urge isn’t just a pre-written origin, but a canvas for some of the most intense character storytelling in the game. And there’s perhaps no class more suited to telling that story than the one that literally lives and dies by its moral codes.

Baldur’s Gate 3

9/10

Released

August 3, 2023

ESRB

M for Mature: Blood and Gore, Partial Nudity, Sexual Content, Strong Language, Violence

Engine

Divinity 4.0